Will AI replace graphic designers, and what is left for the artists?

5 min read

AI has taken the routine side of design, and for content designers who only finish the task the job is going. Aziz Musa on what AI has not taken, and how artists can sell feeling instead.

Will AI replace graphic designers, and what is left for the artists?

The episode is in Arabic

Contents
  1. Will AI replace graphic designers who just finish the task?
  2. Which kind of content designer are you?
  3. What has AI already taken from design work?
  4. What can AI not take from designers?
  5. What would I do if I were an artist?
  6. Are you a feeling designer?

Will AI replace graphic designers? For a lot of them, it already has. The people I feel sorriest for right now are content designers. AI-made content is close to the quality most of them produce, and anyone can now make it. So I want to ask anyone who designs content for a living one honest question: are you a content designer, or are you an artist? The episode is in Arabic, and this page sets out the same argument in writing.

Will AI replace graphic designers who just finish the task?

If your main aim is to finish the task, make the content, make the ad and hand it to the client, the truth is that AI has either ended your job already or will end it soon. Freelancers feel it first. Their clients come from platforms, friends and contacts, and they are usually small companies that have no designer in-house and are trying to keep costs down. If they find that for around 30 dollars a month they can make any amount of content at the same quality as yours, they will not need you at all.

Freelancers already know this. Prices have dropped a long way, and what clients ask for has risen a long way. A client who used to offer 50 dollars for ten social media posts now offers 50 dollars for a thousand. They understand the work has become automated, and they price it that way.

Which kind of content designer are you?

There are two kinds of people making content. The first studied art, often fine art at university, and has been drawing since childhood. The second may have studied something close to it but fell into the job. They loved the technology and Photoshop, learned the software and found an income in it. Three or four years ago there were not enough content designers to go round, and it was one of the hardest roles to fill, so a lot of people came in that way.

If you are in the second group, my advice is plain. Look for other work, ideally something you actually love, and stick with it. If you are in the first group, a real artist, I have better news. Your future looks good, and the work ahead of you may pay more, and there may be more of it.

What has AI already taken from design work?

It has taken anything you repeat. Cutting out photos, colour grading, swapping backgrounds, choosing a font: the mechanical, routine work is finished. Take display advertising. Resizing one design into around 30 sizes, one for every placement, used to take a day, two or three, and with two campaigns it could take a week. AI does it in one go. The same goes for variations of one design and for mock-ups of how a website or a layout will look.

The quality bar has moved as well. Five years ago, if a designer put real effort into a beautiful design, I would have expected it to spread about 80 to 90 per cent of the time, because most content on social media was poor and anything with obvious human effort stood out. The general level has risen since then. The same design that spread five years ago now gets an ordinary result. That is why I say plainly that if you design content and do not use AI, I am surprised you still have clients. Even artists need it for the volume it allows.

What can AI not take from designers?

The first thing AI has not taken is taste. Taste is completely human. It changes with every generation: the taste of the eighties was not the taste of the nineties or the 2000s, and neither is the taste of now. Taste is being able to choose the thing that will move an audience, and that depends on feeling and influence, two things AI does not have.

Influence and feeling are two things AI doesn't have and can't have.

The second is the brand, in the full sense. A brand is a feeling you plant inside your audience. It is the colours and the logo, and it is also the smell when you walk into a restaurant, the clothes the staff wear, the lighting, and the way a customer is treated on the phone. Most of what shapes a brand is human.

The third is persuading a client that this is the right way. AI tends to agree with you. Tell it black and it will meet you at grey. It is built to keep you using it, whether you are right or not. After twenty years of working with audiences, I do not think it can yet tell a client that they are wrong and bring them round. For why design fundamentals still matter, see our episode on designing in the age of AI.

What would I do if I were an artist?

I would stop selling content design. Selling content design is like selling rice: everyone has it, it is all the same rice at the same price, and it comes down to volume. I would turn the whole pitch around and sell the fact that a company's content is not moving its audience.

I would go through companies on Facebook and Instagram one by one, the ones using AI, which is most of them, and show them the gap. This design got six interactions. Look back through your own history: content like this used to get 600. What is the difference? I can show you, because I am a human being and an artist, and an artist understands how an audience will feel about your content and how it will react.

That matters because the aim of marketing is not to sell products. It is to create a feeling that changes behaviour. Content on its own does not do that. Content that creates feeling does, and that is a completely different thing. So I would offer to train a company's designers to see that difference, and to make content that moves their audience. We made the same argument in why content is dead and impact is what matters.

Are you a feeling designer?

If you are an artist, never introduce yourself as a content designer again. You are a feeling designer. You can create feeling, and that makes a big difference to a company. It is also expensive, and very few designers can do it. Stop selling content and sell feeling. It is worth more, and no AI can imitate it.

Questions people ask

Will AI replace graphic designers?

For designers whose job is to finish the task, largely yes. Small companies and freelance clients can now get the same volume of routine content for around 30 dollars a month. Designers who are artists, with real taste and a feel for the audience, still have a future, and may be able to charge more.

What can AI not do in design?

AI has not taken taste, which changes with every generation, or the brand as a whole feeling: smell, clothes, lighting, how a customer is treated. It also cannot persuade a client they are wrong. It tends to agree with whoever is using it.

How can a designer stay valuable as AI improves?

Use AI for the repetitive work, then sell what it cannot do. Show companies the gap between what their AI content gets and what their best content used to get, train their designers to see the difference, and make content that creates feeling and changes behaviour.

The two-minute diagnostic shows which pattern your marketing is in

The diagnostic asks nine questions and names the pattern your marketing is stuck in. No call, no pitch, and you get the paper written for that pattern.