How to choose an SEO company or agency, and when not to hire one
How to choose an SEO company, or any marketing supplier, comes down to a handful of questions most proposals cannot survive. It also comes down to knowing the three times you should buy nothing at all.

Contents
- Start with the outcome you need this year
- Why "is SEO worth it" is the wrong question
- How to choose an SEO company, specifically
- The questions that separate a good supplier from a bad one
- When you should not hire anyone yet
- Which industries need search most, and which do not
- What the contract should say
- The honest answer to "is digital marketing legit"
Start with the outcome you need this year
Why "is SEO worth it" is the wrong question
How to choose an SEO company, specifically
The questions that separate a good supplier from a bad one
- What number will you be accountable for, and what happens if it does not move?
- Who exactly works on this account, and will they be the same people in month nine?
- What would make you tell us to stop spending?
- Tell me about a client you failed, and what you changed afterwards.
- What does your report say in a month that went badly?
- What do you need from us, and what happens if we do not provide it?
When you should not hire anyone yet
Which industries need search most, and which do not
What the contract should say
- The outcome. One sentence, in writing, that both sides would recognise as success twelve months from now.
- Who owns what. Your ad accounts, your analytics, your domain and your content, in your name, from day one. If the supplier holds any of those, you are not a client.
- Notice. Thirty days after an agreed initial period. Long lock-ins with no exit protect the supplier's revenue, not your result.
- Where media spend sits. Paid to the platform by you, visible in your own accounts, never folded inside a retainer where the margin cannot be seen.
The honest answer to "is digital marketing legit"
Questions people ask
How do I know if a marketing agency is any good before I sign?
Ask what number they will be accountable for, who will actually do the work in month nine, and what their report says in a bad month. A good supplier answers all three without hedging, and will usually tell you what they need from you in return. Vague answers to those questions are the answer.
Should I hire an SEO consultant or an agency?
A consultant is often better value when the work is diagnosis, strategy and a short list of pages to fix, because you get their own hands on it. An agency makes sense when the work needs several skills at once, such as content, technical fixes, design and links running in parallel over months.
How long should I give a new agency before judging it?
Six months for direction and twelve for a fair verdict on search. Paid media should show something within a quarter, because you can buy traffic immediately and the only question is whether it converts. If the first ninety days produce no agreed number and no honest reporting, do not wait for month twelve.
The two-minute diagnostic shows which pattern your marketing is in
The diagnostic asks nine questions and names the pattern your marketing is stuck in. No call, no pitch, and you get the paper written for that pattern.